Top Pick for Pool Builders in Columbus
1
Serenity Pools
#1 in Columbus
5.0(51 reviews)
8142 Concord Rd, Delaware, OH 43015, USA, Columbus, OH
Why they ranked: 5.0★ · 51 reviews
Ranked by our methodology combining Google ratings, review volume, response rate, and recency. Updated April 2026.
8142 Concord Rd, Delaware, OH 43015, USA, Columbus, OH
Why they ranked: 5.0★ · 51 reviews
Connect with top pool builders pros in Columbus.
Ranking factors
Star rating — We weight Google star ratings most heavily. Higher average ratings earn more points. Ratings below 3.0 earn nothing on this factor.
Review volume — More reviews means more confidence. We use a Bayesian adjustment so a 5-star business with 3 reviews doesn't outrank a 4.8-star business with 200 reviews.
Claimed listing — Businesses that have claimed their listing and actively manage their profile receive a bonus. This signals an engaged, responsive owner.
Responds to reviews — Businesses that reply to customer reviews show they value feedback. This earns a modest ranking bonus.
Recency — A business with recent reviews (in the past 12 months) ranks higher than one with the same rating but no recent activity. Older review profiles decay linearly.
372 Morrison Rd Suite A, Columbus, OH 43213, USA, Columbus, OH
Why they ranked: 5.0★ · 25 reviews
3129 Home Rd, Powell, OH 43065, USA, Columbus, OH
Why they ranked: 5.0★ · 22 reviews
7749 Blacks Rd SW, Pataskala, OH 43062, USA, Columbus, OH
Why they ranked: 5.0★ · 18 reviews
2020 James Pkwy, Heath, OH 43056, USA, Columbus, OH
Why they ranked: 5.0★ · 10 reviews
5527 OH-273, Belle Center, OH 43310, USA, Columbus, OH
Why they ranked: 4.9★ · 45 reviews
101 Bermuda Dr, Johnstown, OH 43031, USA, Columbus, OH
Why they ranked: 4.8★ · 22 reviews
10496 Parks Ct, Marysville, OH 43040, USA, Columbus, OH
Why they ranked: 4.7★ · 76 reviews
7750 Green Meadows Dr b1, Lewis Center, OH 43035, USA, Columbus, OH
Why they ranked: 4.7★ · 17 reviews
4445 Weaver Ct #1, Hilliard, OH 43026, USA, Columbus, OH
Why they ranked: 4.6★ · 53 reviews
Only businesses with 3+ Google reviews are eligible. Paid listings never influence ranking order.
Side-by-side ratings, services, and reviews between Serenity Pools and Aquatic Creations of Ohio.
See full comparison →Browse pool builders by zip code or neighborhood in Columbus.
Browse by zip code →