Top Pick for Pool Builders in New York
1
The Pool Boss
#1 in New York
5.0(545 reviews)
1474 NJ-23 Ste 8, Wayne, NJ 07470, USA, New York, NY
Why they ranked: 5.0★ · 545 reviews
Ranked by our methodology combining Google ratings, review volume, response rate, and recency. Updated April 2026.
1474 NJ-23 Ste 8, Wayne, NJ 07470, USA, New York, NY
Why they ranked: 5.0★ · 545 reviews
Connect with top pool builders pros in New York.
Ranking factors
Star rating — We weight Google star ratings most heavily. Higher average ratings earn more points. Ratings below 3.0 earn nothing on this factor.
Review volume — More reviews means more confidence. We use a Bayesian adjustment so a 5-star business with 3 reviews doesn't outrank a 4.8-star business with 200 reviews.
Claimed listing — Businesses that have claimed their listing and actively manage their profile receive a bonus. This signals an engaged, responsive owner.
Responds to reviews — Businesses that reply to customer reviews show they value feedback. This earns a modest ranking bonus.
Recency — A business with recent reviews (in the past 12 months) ranks higher than one with the same rating but no recent activity. Older review profiles decay linearly.
Why they ranked: 5.0★ · 75 reviews
Why they ranked: 5.0★ · 33 reviews
1282 Broadhollow Rd, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA, New York, NY
Why they ranked: 4.9★ · 259 reviews
87 Sproat St FL 2, Middletown, NY 10940, USA, New York, NY
Why they ranked: 5.0★ · 9 reviews
Why they ranked: 5.0★ · 7 reviews
144-146 Rossiter Ave, Paterson, NJ 07502, USA, New York, NY
Why they ranked: 4.8★ · 423 reviews
4724 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island, NY 10309, USA, New York, NY
Why they ranked: 4.7★ · 543 reviews
5 Apple Meadow Rd, Hudson, NY 12534, USA, New York, NY
Why they ranked: 4.7★ · 223 reviews
2006 NY-94, Salisbury Mills, NY 12577, USA, New York, NY
Why they ranked: 4.7★ · 16 reviews
Only businesses with 3+ Google reviews are eligible. Paid listings never influence ranking order.
Side-by-side ratings, services, and reviews between The Pool Boss and Rogliano Pools.
See full comparison →Browse pool builders by zip code or neighborhood in New York.
Browse by zip code →